(I saw this days ago and was hoping someone would run with it because I was preoccupied…. alas on one has so I am playing catch up.)
As anyone who has followed the rise and fall of Common Core through it’s stealthy and masked implementation inside the Race To The Top, knows it is now called by another name… JYAKWRAL or “college and career ready”..
Every piece of literature from the educational department, now uses the terms “college and career ready”… Common Core is only linked to whenever an antique reference is required… Maryland publicly denounced “Common Core”, and Lillian Lowery changed Maryland’s Program officially to “College and Career Ready.”
It is a misnomer. “College and Career Ready” sounds good, right? After all…. wouldn’t you want your son or daughter to be college or career ready after spending k-12 years in public schools? You certainly wouldn’t want them to be “college or career unready”…
And that is how these things get accepted.
“College and Career Ready” means what to you?….______________________ , Most likely you answered that it means someone is ready for college or ready for a career. That is how I would have answered it as late as a year ago…
Now here is what college and career ready… really is…
I’m going to steer you to a report from a city close by, which the news media panned just the words of the official, without seeing any of the implications of what it portends…
The city was Camden. It has it’s new educational czar stepping into his new job…. Paymon Rouhanifard, superintendent, announced that he had his work cut out for him. He had only 3 students who were “college or career ready” in his whole district….
Of course anyone who has ever driven through Camden to get to its great aquarium, is mentally prepared to expect the worst out of Camden. So upon hearing this spoken, it sadly does not stretch our bounds of disbelief…
It should have. Even in Camden…
As rebutted by New Jersey’s teachers union”
A more accurate assessment, said its spokesperson, would be to look at those who actually went on to college and are still there. Take 2011! “The graduates of Camden’s five high schools, four public schools and a public charter school, have enormous college attendance rates,” Wollmer said. That includes a third of Camden High graduates and all of those who went to the LEAP academy. Yet few reached the 1550 score on SAT’s that would make them “college ready”.
“That includes a third of Camden High graduates”
So one third of Camden Schools graduates are going to college (Yay! A pure triumph of human endeavor over adversity appreciated in full by anyone who’s been through Camden) and only 3… only 3… in case you didn’t get it… only 3 are college ready?….
What does that tell you? WHAT does THAT tell you? WHAT DOES THAT TELL YOU!!!
If you think for yourself, and don’t let other people put their own thoughts into your head, you are probably thinking this “college and career ready” is one messed up piece of crap..
You would probably want to know, where do they get this standard? College and career ready is what exactly? How do they get that?
Being “college and career ready” is benchmarked at being over 1550 Score on the SAT…
“College and Career Ready” is a 1550 score on the SAT…..
8 people who scored lower that 1550 were accepted for entrance into Harvard in 2012…. 6 people who scored lower than 1550 were accepted by Yale.in 2012.. University of Florida accepted 40 of its entrance class of 2012 from below 1550..
As an employer, would you turn away a Harvard Graduate applying to your firm, because his entrance SAT score was below 1550?….Of course not.
And yet one third of Camden’s graduating class is in College. Whereas the national average is 66% of a graduating class going forward, one would expect Camden to be less. Just like one would expect Watts to be less, ore would expect the Bronx to be less, one would expect eastern Kentucky to be less, it is less.
But only 3 students are “college or career” ready?
Where does that standard emanate?
Now if you have a heart condition and are reading further, you need to take your nitroglycerin … now!. If you’re on stimulants including caffeine, you need to stop, come back and finish this later. Because what you are about to learn will upset you. It will make you very angry.
1550 is an arbitrary number.
It represents out of all those going into colleges and out of all those taking the SAT, the midpoint number where half of those below will have a 65% chance of having a GPA under a B minus and half of those above will have a 65% chance of having a GPA over a B minus….. if you didn’t follow that math, then you obviously have not been through David Coleman‘s mathematical curriculum.
That is what college and career ready means… 1550 …. an arbitrary number where if you are over, you have a 65% chance of getting a grade over a B-… If you are under 1550 you have a 65% chance of having a grade average under a B-.
It doesn’t mean anything. You can have a 1500 (under by 50) score and still have a 35% chance of having over a B- or.. you can have a score of 1600 (over by 50) and have a 35% chance of having below a B-… it is entirely arbitrary. It is ridiculous to tie the educational policy of the entire United States of America to such a random figure.
Now if you go to the College Boards website and pull up their 2012 numbers…. you must start at the beginning, because it is rather unbelievable and you must see it in person to believe it.. I cannot envision why they decided to publish this, because it completely destroys their entire argument for promoting college and career ready…. Why would anyone do that?
It starts with findings from the class of 2013….
a chart with a straight line showing that between 44% and 43% of students from 2009 to 2013 meet the benchmark…
It then states 57% are under.
We have to do better than this it exclaims….
From the data it gives, one must readily ask…. why?
Why if 44 and 43 percent are college ready and that is unchanged, not just on this graph, but back though all the Bush presidency years, back through all the Clinton presidency years, and if one backs out and counters the pre-written test portion fo the SAT, back through the HW Bush years, back through the Reagan years, and back through the Carter years… the score or its equivalent of 1550 has always had the same benchmark between 44 and 43 percent….
If that score was good for your parents, who all got good jobs, raised you, and if you are under 30 are probably helping you keep your head above the economic waters right now, then why is it so horribly bad right now for tomorrow’s students?
It isn’t. “College and Career Ready” is nothing more than a scare tactic… It is like your first grade teacher saying, your daughter got a B. She’ll never get into Harvard if she keeps that up. Get her a tutor now!…
Well what if I don’t want her to go to a pissy crappy school like Harvard. I’d rather put her in a good decent school like Carleton.
But to make elemental changes to the education system, ones that do not benefit any students btw, but bring tons of money into those think tanks surrounding the Beltway, one must create a crisis. Similarly, if one were self-employed being a arms distributor, one must create a war now and then to stay in business.
What that solid line on the above graph does actually do… , is give tremendous credibility to the SAT. A test that consistently shows that it holds regularity over such long periods of time, means it is still a good judge of a student’s ability and probably should continue to be used to determine a child’s probability to succeed in a college environment. With that, we need no individual test consortiums; neither PAARC and Smart Balanced Assessments. We already have the SAT and it has held up well, very well, over time….
But that is an aside. What we are discussing here is the definition of “college and career ready”. A term which plays upon our hopes for all our children, by making us want to make it happen.
When one tries to shock you with a statement there are always two responses that should go off in your head… One, is how did we let this get so bad, and the other is, wait a minute, with what criteria are you making such a statement because I find it hard to believe we suddenly have a crisis materializing out of thin air.
If we agree with the criteria and it seems reasonable that the condition is thus, then we should become alarmed….
In this case, where over 30% of Camden’s graduates go on to post secondary education, for Governor Christie to “create” another traffic-study type of crises by echoing in his State-of-the-State that only 3 of Candem’s students are “College and Career Ready,” can only mean the “College and Career Ready” Curriculum has got to go, and all those promoting such nonsense, have got to go as well……
It is a ridiculous fabrication bordering on the premise behind the Hans Christian Anderson story of the Emperor’s New Clothes..