
Amber Waves Of Grain; Purple Mountains Majesty
Photo Courtesy of Barb&Kathleen@ ThriftTalkDiva
Four out of 5 U.S. adults struggle with joblessness, near-poverty or reliance on welfare for at least parts of their lives, the Associated Press reported this weekend. I know a lot of adults breathed a sigh of relief going: “whew… at least I’m not the only one.”
One can shrug their shoulders and say that’s the way it is supposed to be, I guess. Not much one can do about it.
But to do so, one has to forget their lives growing up. Where their parents made do, often having something extra to pass down to us, their children, when they moved on.
Whether it was a house, a small savings, they lived well enough, They died with dignity knowing they started with nothing, and actually “made it.” Today, comparatively, the baby boomers started out wealthy and now have nothing to give their children, except their debt.
How did this happen?
The year was 2001. Bush was elected and Republicans had a majority in the House, and were one shy in the Senate. Time to implement the election winner’s policy. The campaign was run on tax cuts, and tax cuts we were going to have….
On the floor of Congress, the debate took place like this: “Look” the Democrats said, “we have a stable economy with the national debt hitting 0 in 7 years. Why do you want to mess around with that?”
Republicans replied: … “Tax Cut. Tax Cut.. Get your tax cuts here.” and America began its swirl down the toilet.
The Democrats countered: “if you cut taxes now, in 15 years the rich will have all the money, and the middle class will become poor. A society can’t be all about “making a profit”. As with a business, there has to be continuous reinvestment back into the economy; otherwise sooner or later the supporting structure runs out of juice, gets tired of holding everything up, and it all crashes down….”
Republicans replied: … “Tax Cut. Tax Cut.. Get your tax cuts here, ” and it was done.
With a party supporting their every wish, the wealthy started dismantling the single biggest drawback keeping them from earning top dollar: the middle class.
The argument became: we aren’t making enough profit. Everything had to go that got in the way making a profit. Making a profit became how we identified ourselves. Of course that only applied to the corporate world. The US Government was gutted to assist in the making of profit. The Middle Class was gutted to assist with the making of a profit.
How was this done? The word “no” was used to respond to all increased payroll requests. And our expenses that benefited major corporations, kept edging higher. Medical coverage, a necessity, now took a bigger bite out of the no-go-higher paycheck. Utility costs, a necessity, now took a bigger bite out of the same no-go-higher paycheck. Insurance of all kinds, now took a bigger bite out of the same no-go-higher paycheck.
Government itself was cut back, whittled down, eradicating the purchasing power of a lot of those no-go-higher paychecks completely. Soon there were too many people looking for work. Some were desperate to work at all, no matter what the wage. Really? That made those who run companies to ask themselves this question: why should we continue paying Mr. X this high amount, when we can get Ms. Y to work for this with the same productivity? Mr. X joined the lines of the unemployed.
With more Mr. X’s in the unemployment line, those still working accepted more and more stress for the paycheck they still had, and gave more and more concessions to their employer (who mind you, was quite happy before with his more than adequate income while paying out those amounts), digging themselves further and further into the hole.
So the entire middle class is working for less, and paying it all back and more….
According to Republicans, it is all their fault; they are lazy, insolent, disagreeable louts who deserve every bit of pain they’ve received. They are the surplus population that needs to be eradicated from existence, Sorry, but that’s just the way it is..
And was, through American history until the 1930’s.
In the 1930’s Democrats said, “no, it doesn’t have to be this way.” We can tax those with money, have Social Security when we retire, build projects and invest in infrastructure that improve our lives, like electricity, like telephones. You know, we can set prices so people can make a living off what they work. we can set profits so small businesses can live off what they sell; we can make it so everyone can have a house, food on the table, and die with dignity, not being a burden to the next generation.
And that is what they did. They said profit is good. Too much profit is bad, and so we are taking everything over this ascertained level.
And to be honest, it was touch and go for a while, and gradually the meticulous detailed economic planning gave way to market economics, but only after the economic free-fall had been stopped.
And yes the rich screamed ferociously loud (and lost every national election for the next 60 years). But we got the childhood we lived through because of that action.
There was more. We said banks could not invest the money that people needed for their livelihood. That restriction has since been removed. We said, if you paid into Social Security, when you retired, you got something back. That promise is now gone from every Republican platform. Done away with. Eradicated. We said that income taxes were good, they supported the country and made us strong. That held true until we chose to let the wealthy have more, and take less ourselves. We said, of course, it is right for a employees to strike, stop working if the boss won’t pay them correctly. He can’t fire you for striking. Once that was protected, the bosses eventually caved in when he saw paying proper wages was cheaper than the alternative. Over the course of these actions, it enabled a person to go to work for a company, and retire from that company with a pension, with Social Security, with Medicare; they could pay their bills up to the end, and still pass something onto their children, us.
When we get told today by our media that we can’t afford to live like we used to, no one except the bravest of us, dare stand up to ask why? Are you so brow beaten? Are you so numb you can’t see it is you’re own actions that are the cause of your demise? Are you no better than the prodigal son, who squandered his father’s wealth, and now has nothing? You had it all once. Remember the dreams, the life plan you had for yourself when you graduated college?
And how much did it cost you to graduate from that college? As much as a house, as our graduates today now face? A tab so high Just so those who lent the money can make 10 times the amounts they made back when you and I were lent money to put ourselves through school?
So the problem is very simple. Very small. Giving more money to the wealthy, the rich, the multinational corporations, takes money that should be ours, right out of our pocket. It is that simple. That is where we went wrong. That is how we got here. Four out of five adults facing poverty.
There is no guaranteed right that one must make a profit. It’s not in the Bible. It is not in the Constitution. Everything does not have to give just so you can make more money. There are things on this planet far more important than how much “extra” money you can squeeze out of your fellow human beings.
All that we need to do to rejuvenate the middle class, is control excessive profit. Not in a heavy handed way, mind you, but through proper levels of taxation. Profit is extra. It’s superfluous money. A business can run fine without making a profit. In fact, most small businesses do. They are trying to survive like you and I, with loans, with IOU’s, with barter arrangements, with reinvestment, with building on, etc.
Remember how life used to be so good. Now four out of five adults will, if not already, face poverty before they die. Four out of five. Is that the promise we got when we were told to stand by our desks, put our hands on our hearts, and mumble to squeeze some fun out of the daily ritual…. ” I pledge allegiance, to the flag, of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands; one nation under God, indivisible; with liberty and justice for all.” Did we go to school, go to college, marry, raise a family, struggle to put them through school, for this? Four out of five of us living in poverty?
And it took place while we worked very hard, getting conned into giving away all the things we every had all rights to, simply because we once elected the Republican Party of the United States of America into power. Happy with yourself now?
Let’s get that dream back. Screw their profits; rebuild America back into its beautiful dream, now. Let’s give our children their dream back! At least that is something worthy. That would make it all worth while.
15 comments
Comments feed for this article
July 29, 2013 at 2:29 pm
delacrat
“How did this happen?
The year was 2001. Bush was elected and Republicans had a majority in the House, and were one shy in the Senate.”
The seeds were sown long before Bush and the Democrats are not without clean hands either.
Recall that the Glass-Stiegal Act repeal was signed off by Bill Clinton in cahoots with a Republican Congress.
July 29, 2013 at 2:39 pm
delacrat
with clean hands
July 29, 2013 at 3:11 pm
kavips
True, but would it have happened without the Republican Congress? Without Newt Gingrich? I don’t think so. Bill Clinton signed it, and he is a Democrat. But had there been a Democratic Congress, it never would have come upon his desk. He didn’t champion for it if I remember.
And I remember the arguments for. And the endorsements that piece of legislation received from a lot of neutral economists who said we could progress safely with the limitations of Glass Stiegal removed.
And if we hadn’t passed Senator Gramm’s bill to deregulate derivitives, remove all government oversite the next year, there is a good chance the prediction of those economists might have held up….
But when you allow gambling, gambling with the nation’s money, sooner or later the dice turn the other way.
The begging question, instead of saying Democrats are guilty too, is to ask, who is the more capable party to get us out of this mess, who will return us to the New Deal policies that are time tested and worked so well?
Democrats? Republicans? Libertarians? IPOD’rs? Greens? or Blue Enigma’s?
July 30, 2013 at 1:40 am
John Egan
Until you acknowledge that the Dems have been in cahoots, you won’t get very far in your analysis.
July 30, 2013 at 1:41 am
John Egan
PS – I posted before reading other comments. I find it humorous that delacrat and I both used “cahoots”. Hmmmm – –
July 30, 2013 at 4:51 am
kavips
Cahoots to you both… 🙂 Sorry, but I don’t agree. I think my analysis has gone very far already. For what you are suggesting is myth. However upon re-reading your question, it appears that the difference between our interpretations, most likely lies in the number underlying your interpretation of “the Dems”… If you mean 1 or 2 than I would agree. It is just that for purity reasons, I wouldn’t count that as “the Dems” however. But if you mean totals over 25%, then I’d have to see the specific data you’d offer before believing it. 25% of the Dems would be between 10 and 15 in the Senate, and between 50 and 55 in the House.
Show me a Democratic vote total over those amounts for specific bills to reduce income taxes on the wealthy; for removing an employee’s right to strike, for privatizing Social Security, for stripping the FDA, for stripping the SEC, for eradicating Medicare, for deregulating banks, for eliminating NPR and Voice of America, and we’ll talk.
Even then, it is still a stretch to blame a whole party for the actions of 25%, even if you do find one Republican bill which had that many Dems pile on.
So no, It’s a myth that both parties are at fault. A myth played up by Republicans and echoed by the media.. I’ve been watching the vote totals for years. Truth is, except for the second Gulf War, Democrats rarely voted with the Republican party. The idea that Democrats are also to blame needs proof. .
Do you have a vote total that proves your claim?
July 31, 2013 at 12:00 am
John Egan
Clinton’s signature “Welfare Reform” –
House – only 23% of Dems supported
But Senate – 53% of Dems supported
Including such luminaries as Reid, Biden, and Kerry
(Opponents Kennedy, Pell, and Wellstone are now gone)
This was a Contract on American piece that neoliberal Dems helped pass.
Bush’s Iraq War Resolution
House – 39% of Dems supported
Senate – 58% of Dems supported – jeez!
And, of course, military interventions have had no economic impact.
Fortunately, the wars only cost $50B as Rumsfeld predicted.
PS – Looks like by the time Dems reach the Senate,
they are well in cahoots.
July 31, 2013 at 12:45 pm
kavips
First thank you for taking the time to dig that up. But if that is the best you can do, you sort of proved the point that the collapse we are in, is due only because of Republican majorities had more votes than Democrat minorities.
Our collapse is not due to Welfare Reform. In fact that freed countless workers for the low level part time positions opening up in the Clinton Boom economy towards the end of the millennium.
Our collapse was, I will give you this one, partly due to the Iraqi War, but was more due to the fact that we chose not to fund the war as it progressed, but to borrow and make our children (and us now) be forced to pay for it if not in increased taxes, then in cut services. Both affecting the speed of the economic rebound.
Democrats were far more forgiving of other Democrats voting pro-war, because of one, 9/11, was fraught on everyones mind, and two, those who voted against a more justified war in the past (1st gulf War), were ridiculed as cowards and shamed out of office…. Proving the point that if in a perfect world, there were no Republicans, things might have gone far differently and life today, would be so much better.
If your retirement is over a million right now, you are in very good shape. But if Gore had won, not Bush, most of baby boom middle class America would have that much on hand from accumulated value in what they’d put in during the 90’s…
Votes have consequences and a vote for any Republican is a vote against everyone making under $500,000…..
August 1, 2013 at 1:04 am
John Egan
Clearly, you have imbibed deeply of the Dem Party Kool-Aid.
After a lifetime of Democratic activism – local, state, national; donating, GOTV, and voting – – I dropped my Dem registration two years ago. It was bad enough with the DLC neoliberalism of the Clintons, now with Obama we have fascism-lite. Are the Goppers bat-shit crazy? You betcha. But that doesn’t mean that the Democratic Party is anything more than a turd in the punchbowl.
I know many people like me. Wouldn’t be a big deal if we walked away – – IF – – there were oodles of young people to replace us as party activists. But after eight years of Obama and all of his mellifluous rhetoric, I suspect most will be burnt out on the Dem Party, too.
August 1, 2013 at 11:39 am
kavips
A) There is no Democratic Kool Aid. The reality of dealing with Republicans still entrenched in power, totally shoots that misconception in the foot. Republicans, like that Holmes guy in Aurora, are so crazy they have defined the reality of the moment, absurd as it is. Democrats have been reduced to dealing with a crazy man intent on wrecking havoc and destruction, and possibly killing us all for his own sport, because in his own mind, it’s the “cool” thing to do.
B) Your personal story rings very hollow. I’m not buying it. Means you would have dropped your registration in July 2011, just as the Republican primaries were getting under way. No one! No one would be an activist in the Democratic Party and then go vote for Romney. No one! One of those two factoids has to be false.
I believe that as much as I would believe someone would strip, roll around in poison ivy, because they love the smell of its resin on their skin. 🙂
But you are certainly welcome to try to sell me on the concept. For entertainment if for nothing else..
August 1, 2013 at 2:14 pm
John Egan
BTW – I’m immune to poison ivy. We played army as a kid and one of our “bases” was a ditch filled with poison ivy. Actually, we DID roll in poison ivy. Some of the kids ended up in the hospital. I got one bump.
Now – – – on to more germane matters. It is truly pathetic that you discount my personal experience. That suggests that it is useless having any communication, since you will believe what you wish – regardless. Sorry, amigo, but I DID opt out. Doesn’t mean I supported Romney, either. One can leave the Democratic Party without joining the Republicans – – ya know? People like you are why we left in the first place – and why we are unlikely to return.
Buh-bye.
August 1, 2013 at 2:30 pm
kavips
I knew I was right. You’re so busted. 🙂 Everyone else would have explained why they didn’t fit in with the normal prognosis.
August 1, 2013 at 4:54 pm
John Egan
What an arrogant little shit you are.
Not only are you an arrogant shit – –
Your arrogance is the very thing which drives people away.
The only argument remaining for the Dems is:
“If you don’t vote for us, you’ll get th-th-them!”
In most cases, I’ll vote for neither.
And I could really care less who gets elected.
August 1, 2013 at 4:54 pm
John Egan
PS – Considering you hail from the state owned by the financial industrial, you really have a lot of nerve.
August 2, 2013 at 1:00 am
kavips
John, you said considering I hail from a state owned by the financial industrial, Therefore I must have a lot of nerve. What the heck does that mean?
I do have a good amount of nerve and that is a positive thing, but that trait would exist any state where I was addressing someone who pretends to be something they aren’t. Let me save you a retort.
You expect everyone to believe you were pro choice then flipped to anti abortion?
You expect everyone to believe you were pro union, then flipped to become anti union.
You expect everyone to believe you were against tax cuts, and now are for them.
You expect everyone to believe you were for getting out of Afghanistan and now are for staying in.
You expect everyone to believe you were anti gun, and now you are against any law that regulates guns.
You expect everyone to believe you were for using tax money to invest in our infrastructure, or basically follow the Keynesian plan of economics. Now you are against any government spending at all, including Social Security and Medicare..
You expect everyone to believe you were for bailing out Detroit in 2009, and now you think they should have gone bankrupt.
You expect everyone to believe things are as you say. Well, you have to meet the probability test at first. Saying one used to be an active democrat, using your words here… “After a lifetime of Democratic activism – local, state, national; donating, GOTV, and voting – – I dropped my Dem registration two years ago
No one is going to believe that, when the number of people identifying themselves as Republicans were at 42% of the American population in 2008 and now, are just under 17%. You are going the wrong way from everyone else..Everyone is running out of the Republican Party like its huge dinner and the last person has to pay the bill. Doesn’t that sound a little strange to you, that someone would be attracted to the party of pure evil, instead of running away?
Here on this blog you got to have facts or you get shredded… Thinking you are in Oklahoma, or another stupid red state, where you can say “i used to be a democrat but they sucked and now I’m a republican. Woot, woot, woot”, and people will believe you, was your big mistake.
There is a reason Republicans are dying. They suck. The suck royally, and they are even bad at sucking but they can’t get elected doing anything else… America is doing its best to get them un-elected.
America is tired of them… Really tired of them… Got anything to prove me wrong? Here I’ll answer for you… so you don’t have to respond… “No”.
Of course Republicans are really great people when they don’t mention politics. Love them to death. Got nothing against them when they are real human beings and not some sock puppet that brags he rolls in poison ivy, expecting strangers to believe him because he says so… …