Common Core is being defeated. Some states like Delaware are doubling down which is about as effective as using children fo stem the Russian Invasions of Berlin. Most states are abandoning the idea before they lose their investment…..
Common Core is actually uniting various groups once thought completely unmixable, bonding them in opposition to its implementation. Called “Obamacore” by Conservatives.. Called a “Mistake” by Teachers Unions. Called a “Boondoggle” by state legislators trying to find ways to pay for its cost. Called a “National Disgrace” by Progressives worried over its damage to our international competitiveness. Called a “Tyranny” by the Tea Party, outraged over the complete loss of local control…
One entity still defends it. Wall Street and those who serve it.
For those of you who don’t know, Common Core was actually developed by our state’s Governors. Jack Markell was a one of the leaders who pushed this. The program was then adopted by Obama and under his secretary of Education, Arne Duncun, all federal money as been tied to its implementation.
In fairness, I like Common Core. It embodies most of the ideas I have stressed since blogging. However, though it sounds great in theory, I must admit, it is not working. Our children are being denied a great education because we are teaching remedial math and remedial English over and over again for one reason…. to boost test scores. The reason for this focus on test scores,is because that is how we determine which schools we will close down, which principals will be forced to resign, and which teachers will be fired.
Obviously in that environment, all a child will learn, is how to take the test, and how to score the most points with their answers. Nothing of which will help them or help us in the real world when they become our newest generation of the employed….
The problem is not with the principles or aims of Common Core. The problem lies with the tests and their current use as a weapon to hold over people’s heads. The tests were meant to be used as a tool for analysis… How much did Johnny know in September. How much does Johnny know in January? How much will Johnny know in June? What a great tool if it were honestly applied and not doctored up, contorted, or flagrantly adjusted in order to prevent a horrible outcome that has absolutely nothing to do with each student’s educational needs!
From the American Teachers Union –Randi Weingarten….““The Common Core is in trouble, There is a serious backlash in lots of different ways, on the right and on the left.”
Across the nation states are rushing out tests based on the new standards without preparing teachers and designing new curricula… Here the states are saying… “Take this test you’ve never seen. If you don’t do good, you’ll lose your job.” “Kid, on this test you’ve never seen, you did bad. You can’t graduate despite your 4.0 average.” “Ladies and Gentlemen; parents of this district! Your attention please! We have to close this school because your students, failed this test on stuff they’ve never seen.”
That is why parents are fighting back. 8 moms in Texas have pushed a bill in Texas to roll back the number of tests required to graduate from 15 to 5. Governor Perry will veto it.
That is why one child in five fails the Texas standard tests.
Alabama, Indiana, Georgia and South Dakota have legislation ongoing to pull or modify Common Core Standards.
Kentucky just had a 30-40 point drop in scores because of Common Core. The assessment you took this year was much more rigorous than anything that you’ve had before. It takes three or four years for the teachers and the kids to catch up.
But legislators are not the ground level.. Teachers are. New York put a message board so teachers could comment on issues they were having with Common Core implementation….. Most of the comments are negative.
My sixth grader was in tears after the second day of the test. Didn’t even get to the essay – has NEVER had that happen before. What’s the point of making kids feel this awful about themselves? He’s a good student, now he feels terrible
What’s up with reading four pages of directions to the kids before they start? My English Language Learners were in a daze…
Watched my child do test prep booklets, test prep mornings, test prep afterschool, even test prep Saturdays. Then she didn’t even get to finish the test. Taking her to a bookstore this afternoon to find some real reading..
Third graders had to keep rereading and rereading these long answers to find them in the passages. Is that really what we want third graders doing? I’m worried about them poring over these small details forever.
The test wasn’t hard at all but timely. Students couldn’t finish the exam. How can we judge students on an essay when they weren’t able to do the essay because of timing. Common core wasn’t written to test speed reading it was written I believe for deeper comprehension. Its almost as if we set up our students for failure. Also for a company to use text from their books in an exam seems unethical and unfair. Lastly I wonder if the writers of the test should be judged on some of the grammatical errors that occurred in the answers that seemed not to make sense and often times looked like two choices could answer the questions…..
Including questions that were both tedious to interpret and would require the stamina of an Olympic athlete to answer is at best unrealistic, and at worst, cruel. I am also baffled by the decision to include texts that are recommended on the Engage NY website in terms of level of complexity for 7th graders, on a 5th grade exam. Is the message for teachers then that grade-level reading is now inadequate and instead, all students should be reading several grades above their level?…
Is your blood boiling yet? If you have children, I’d be willing to bet it is….
Spend an evening reading what is really going on with Common Core….
Then, do something about it….. Start with calling your Governor….
Lucy Calkins, a professor at Teachers’ College at Columbia University: “I’m a big supporter of the Common Core. I wrote the best-selling book about it,” Calkins said. “But this makes even me question it.”
12 comments
Comments feed for this article
April 30, 2013 at 1:07 pm
John Young
Reblogged this on Transparent Christina.
April 30, 2013 at 3:32 pm
Mike O.
Spend an evening reading what is really going on with Common Core….
Then, do something about it….. Start with calling your Governor….
kavips – your link goes to a page of comments about NYS Common Core test, not about Common Core at all. The comments revealed valid concerns about the test, not Common Core.
Common Core does not specify a test at all. NYS made its own test. Delaware has chosen to join the SBAC test consortium, and SBAC has not started yet in Delaware. Should we call Jack Markell and give him a piece of our mind about the NYS test, which is not the same as ours?
I suppose it would be fair to suggest Markell should avoid the mistakes experienced in the NYS test. After all, SBAC is an organization of states. The time constraints and the overall length of the test are obvious mistakes to avoid.
By the way, the SBAC will be releasing extended practice questions on May 29 that you can take online.
In my opinion, Common Core itself is benign and maybe a slight improvement. The mischief comes in other areas: the testing and the misuse it is put to, and mis-interpretations local educators may make when implementing Common Core. Neither of these is part of Common Core.
April 30, 2013 at 3:46 pm
Nancy Willing
Here is more on the testing data being sold off to Gates, etc. via Wireless Generation-
http://www.nationofchange.org/exposed-how-murdoch-bill-gates-and-big-corporations-are-data-mining-our-schools-1367331290#comments
April 30, 2013 at 5:49 pm
kavips
Thanks for the heads up on May 29th. In regards to Common Core however, a distinction must be made between the theoretical drive and the internal mechanics. One could say the aims of Mussolini were noble as well; he did make the trains run on time but his methods were horrible and created sufficient problems to bring down his government and have himself killed.
I believe I was quite clear that the principles of Common Core were dear to my own. The idea of saying these are items everyone needs to know and should, is very appealing.
But that said, the “reforms” being done in the name of Common Core, are very destructive. It appears we are using the methods of the Spanish Inquisition in our attempt to make Christians out of heathens… I have heard very similar comments visualized on the New York test, right here in Delaware, right across the border in PA, right down I 81 in Tennessee, all the way out in Washington State, and in of course, in Texas… The implementation of Common Core being too complex for bureaucrats, is being handed over to corporate shills who receive the money first, then create it, and they are the ones doing a bad job.
My point which I wish to register, it that no matter how the argument weighs whether the idealism behind Common Core is good or bad, in all regards there is no question of its effect upon our children…
I have outlined the procedures needed to save it.
Uncouple accountability with the assessments..
Increase funds necessary to create an 11 to 1 student ratio.
Focus on making learning fun again….
If that sounds simple, then one hasn’t been paying attention…….
April 30, 2013 at 6:52 pm
John Young
Looks like employees to me: http://www.smarterbalanced.org/about/smarter-balanced-staff/
if all the bad stuff that comes with poor implementation comes, doesn’t that partially condemn the planning and processes that created the CCSS? I know it certainly creates distrust. Especially the kind born out of ignoring parents, which is EXACTLY how CCSS got support in DE, by ignoring/bypassing parents.
April 30, 2013 at 6:59 pm
kavips
John, speaking for myself, I would add as a parent we were sort of marketed out of the equation, if that makes sense… Lulled by a News Journal that still to this day, has not talked anonymously to any teacher and printed a truthful expose that all of us hear almost daily… We were told it was going to be great for our kids, and being busy with the little details of a recession, we trusted that assessment.
All it would take to bring this issue home, , is one YouTube clip surreptitiously taken in a classroom , showing a row of crying third graders trying to take the test, ….
Or a copy of the test to surface… We saw the one question regarding a pineapple that was leaked to the NY Times, which was ridiculed the world over…
April 30, 2013 at 7:18 pm
John Young
we are de-stressing because there is stress methinks. And the adults KNOW IT….
April 30, 2013 at 7:22 pm
John Young
we gave statewide 1st place and iTunes cards to these kids for getting excited about TESTS, not learning, TESTS:
May 1, 2013 at 12:12 am
kavips
I see the de-stressing video is an attempt to sell something… I so thought I was looking at a public service announcement until the end…. Buy our “de-stressing plans”… why am I not surprised?
I was reading of a school that forced teachers to dress up as paparazzi on test day, and rolled down a red carpet for students to strut up into school on that day…. I do know that one Christina District High School had a pep rally for Test Day, with teachers being the cheerleaders… umm. it went over like a rock.
It reminds me of the shenanigans our post office used to excel at on Income Tax Day…. It is more of a distraction than an asset.
In one of the links, I believe it was Nancy’s, “Parents, students and teachers need to band together,and boycott tests that are designed to rank and sort our children and label them failures rather than provide them educational equity…..
It used to be a child could start again in a new school… Now with a national database, … “Your child was put in a remedial class because they scored low in the third grade…” ” But, but, but, they were sick, missed the test, and never were given a chance to make it up…” “Likely story! If that were true, a note about that would be in our records.”..
As with all internet issues, it could be a good thing when handled properly. But paramount is the fact that if parents are guaranteed the right to sue when something goes wrong… I mean if you can fund four years of a prestigious university because Murdoch “tapped” into your child’s file, …. I guess one could live with that….
May 2, 2013 at 4:15 pm
Karen Light
I can not say that I approve of anything in the Common Core. Yes, it is true we need to improve Education in America, but a program that was rushed in from the federal government and full of problems is not what our education system needs. DE signed on before even seeing the standards. There is no shortage of information but I encourage you to read the Paper put forth by the Pioneer Institute. It is very detailed and gives an accurate portrayal of RTTT and Common Core.
You can find the Paper here:
Click to access Controlling-Education-From-the-Top-PRINT.pdf
May 2, 2013 at 8:52 pm
kavips
Thank you Karen. We had a argument here that then went national, when one of our students brought home a homework assignment to analyze a passage about as grocery store manager’s day, and he had a real uneventful day. This was substituted instead of reading classic literature. In the comments coming in from both side, we more or less determined that the guidelines that are on line, in order to market to others what Common Core is about, are hard to find fault with. But somehow those standards were not enforced when it got down to the students level… Whether it is Pearson or another testing company, whether it is the states trying to simply a complex issue to get it done, whether it is the teachers sorting through to ensure what will score on the tests gets taught… or all of the above…. Common Core as a program is not working, even though the marketing makes it sound nice…
July 7, 2014 at 12:58 am
All About Common Core, Charters, and Public Education | kavips
[…] Shattered From the Core, Common Core That Is….. […]